Honk-Key Lock & Safe Blog

The Difference Between Lock Rekeying and Lock Replacement

by | Apr 26, 2025 | Commercial Locksmith Services, Residential Locksmith Services

When a lock stops working correctly, or you need to update your security, you usually face two choices: lock rekeying or lock replacement. At Honk-Key Lock & Safe, we help homeowners and business owners in Montrose, CO choose the right solution for their situation.

Both rekeying and replacement improve security, but they work in different ways. Knowing the difference helps you make a practical and cost-effective decision that protects your property without unnecessary expense.

What Lock Rekeying Means

Rekeying changes the internal pins and tumblers inside a lock so that old keys no longer work. The lock stays in place but is reconfigured to accept a new key. This process is fast, affordable, and ideal when you want to keep your existing hardware but control who has access.

We often recommend rekeying for these situations:

  • You recently moved into a new home or office and want to ensure only you have working keys.
  • You lost a key or had one stolen and need to prevent unauthorized access.
  • You want multiple locks to open with one key, improving convenience.
  • Your locks are in good shape and still operate smoothly.

Rekeying provides new control over who can enter your property without the cost of buying new locks. It’s a simple way to restore peace of mind while keeping your existing hardware.

When Lock Replacement Is the Better Choice

Replacing a lock involves removing the entire unit and installing a new one. It’s the right solution when locks are damaged, outdated, or no longer secure. Replacement also gives you the option to upgrade your security with high-security or smart lock systems.

We suggest replacing locks when:

  • The lock is worn out or broken beyond repair.
  • You want to upgrade to a stronger, higher-security model.
  • The current lock no longer fits the door or latch correctly.
  • You’re remodeling and want new styles or finishes that match your home.

Replacement can also make sense for businesses or properties that need to meet new access control or fire door requirements. Our team installs both traditional and smart lock systems for homes, offices, and commercial doors throughout Montrose.

How to Decide Between Rekeying and Replacing

The right choice depends on the condition of your locks, your security goals, and your budget. Rekeying works best when the hardware is in good condition, while replacement is better when the lock body or mechanism is worn or outdated.

At Honk-Key Lock & Safe, we inspect your locks before making a recommendation. Our locksmiths explain each option clearly so you can make an informed decision. Because we handle both rekeying and replacement, we offer honest advice based on what’s best for your security, not just a quick fix.

Why Professional Service Matters

Whether you’re rekeying or replacing locks, professional installation ensures lasting performance and safety. DIY attempts often lead to misaligned hardware or damaged doors. Our locksmiths carry the right tools and use precise techniques to keep your locks secure and functional.

As a veteran-owned company, we take pride in providing reliable, certified service across Montrose and the surrounding areas. Our training through Lockmasters Security Institute and ASSA ABLOY Academy allows us to handle all lock types, from standard residential locks to advanced access control systems.

Serving Montrose and Western Colorado

Honk-Key Lock & Safe proudly serves Montrose, CO, and nearby communities. We also have a Grand Junction location opening in 2025 to better support customers across the Western Slope. Whether you need rekeying, lock replacement, or security upgrades, our mobile locksmith units are fully equipped to help.

Strengthen Your Security with Honk-Key Lock & Safe

Whether you need rekeying, new locks, or an expert inspection, we’re here to help. Our locksmiths provide honest advice and dependable service to keep your property secure and accessible.

Call (970) 773-0047 for lock rekeying or replacement services in Montrose, CO or learn more about our residential, commercial, automotive, and safe locksmith services.